Looking to invest in a new set of golf irons?
Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced golfer, one of the biggest decisions you’ll have to make is whether to opt for irons with steel or graphite shafts.
Both shaft types have their advantages and drawbacks, but the best option for you comes down to your personal preference.
To help you make an informed choice, let’s take a closer look at the differences between the two.
How do graphite and steel irons compare?
For most golfers, feel and style are important factors to consider when choosing golf irons – but these aren’t the only ones.
Every golfer has unique swing characteristics and dynamic ability, which is why you also need to bear the following in mind when deciding between steel and graphite irons…
· Weight
Graphite shafts weigh between 50g and 85g – making them perfect for golfers that want to generate more power and faster swing speeds.
Irons with stainless steel shafts are typically heavier, weighing between 90g-120g.
· Feel
Golf clubs with steel shafts tend to offer more feedback than their graphite counterparts. They are typically favoured by golfers who are seeking a more solid feel.
As a result of being lighter, graphite irons tend to feel more comfortable and are easier to hit. These also have vibration dampening properties which benefit players with back problems or arthritis – reducing any discomfort when they swing their club.
· Torque
Another crucial factor to consider is the torque (how much the shaft bends and twists)
Generally, graphite irons provide more torque and lateral twisting than their steel counterparts. Offering more forgiveness, these are great for players with low swing speeds.
Steel shafts have less torque, so twist less and provide better ball flight control. This makes them perfect for advanced players who generate faster swing speeds.
· Flex
Graphite irons provide more flex than those with steel shafts, which equates to more power. The only downside to offering greater flexibility is that this can reduce accuracy and feel.
Better players usually have faster swing speeds. And stiffer steel shafts offer more control and increased softness, allowing for more distance.
· Durability
Golf irons with steel shafts are extremely durable, meaning the chances of them breaking are very slim. With the right care and attention, they could last for decades!
Due to their low density and excellent flexibility, graphite shafts are slightly less durable, so may not last as long.
· Performance
If you’re looking for a set of golf irons that are responsive and vibrate upon impact with the ball, those with steel shafts will best suit your performance needs.
However, if you suffer from back problems or arthritis, graphite irons will inhibit vibrations and provide a much smoother feel.
· Cost
As with most things, you get what you pay for with golf irons – but it’s important to set yourself a realistic budget.
If money is tight, it’s worth going down the route of steel irons. These are more durable and affordable than graphite irons, making them a cost-effective addition to your golf bag.
If you can afford to splurge a little extra on golf irons, be sure to consider models with graphite shafts.
Which should you choose?
Historically, steel shafts were better suited to higher swing speed players, whereas their graphite counterparts were ideal for golfers with moderate swing speeds or those who craved maximum distance. But this is no longer the case.
If you’re torn between irons with graphite shafts and steel shafts, our best advice is to arrange a custom club fitting with the team at Clarkes’ Golf Centre. Not only will this give you the opportunity to try both types of irons out before you commit to buying, but we can analyse different aspects of your swing and recommend the most suitable shaft for you.
To benefit from the expertise of our club fitters and establish which shaft type is best, call us on 01744 419 914 today.
